Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel
Pricing & details updated October 2026
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel is one of 2 cremation providers we list in Fishers, IN.
At $2,715, this is the lowest direct cremation price we list in Fishers.
How Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel’s price compares in Fishers
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel lists direct cremation from $2,715. That is the lowest published direct cremation price of the 2 Fishers providers that publish a direct cremation price.
Lowest in Fishers
$2,715
Highest in Fishers
$3,300
Based on the published prices of 2 of the 2 Fishers providers we list. These are listed starting prices, not quotes — ask any provider for a written, itemized price list (your right under the FTC Funeral Rule) before paying.
Jessica helped me complete my advanced planning project. She cared about my wishes and needs over trying to sell me services and products. I appreciated that. She offered information and options. She answered all my questions. She made a discussion I didn't want to have, easy and pleasant.
Jessica was very professional and accommodating to our needs. Her services brought us peace of mind.
Shirley Brothers recently handled the services for my wife. It was a difficult time but the staff were superb in all of their support. I especially want to thank Laura the funeral director. Thanks to her the services went smoothly. My family and I will call on them again when my time comes.
Compare with Other Providers
See how Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel compares side-by-side with the other 1 cremation provider we list in Fishers.
View All 2 Fishers Providers →Free cremation cost tools
Free, no-signup calculators to estimate and compare cremation costs.
Direct Cremation
$2,715
Cremation + Memorial
$5,070
Full Service
$6,835
Own this business?
Get inquiries from families in Fishers. No subscription: pay $40 only for the ones you unlock.
Get Family InquiriesRequest a Free Quote
from Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel and other Fishers providers
Frequently Asked Questions About Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel
How much does direct cremation cost at Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel?
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel lists direct cremation from $2,715 in Fishers, Indiana. That is a listed starting price, not a quote. Ask for a written, itemized price list before paying — any funeral provider must give you one on request under the FTC Funeral Rule. That is the lowest published direct cremation price of the 2 Fishers providers that publish a direct cremation price.
Is Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel cheaper than other cremation providers in Fishers?
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel has the lowest published direct cremation price of the 2 Fishers providers that publish a direct cremation price. We list 2 cremation providers in Fishers in total, 2 of which publish a direct cremation price. Listed prices are starting prices, so compare itemized quotes for the same service before deciding.
What cremation packages does Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel list prices for?
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel publishes starting prices for direct cremation from $2,715, cremation with a memorial service from $5,070 and a full-service funeral with cremation from $6,835. What each package includes varies between providers, so ask for an itemized list of exactly what is and is not covered before comparing those figures with anyone else’s.
How is Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel rated?
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel is rated 4.6 out of 5 from 9 reviews. That rating and review count come from the provider’s public Google listing, not from Local Cremation Guide. A rating says nothing about price, so compare quotes as well as reviews.
Where is Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel located?
Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel is at 9900 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, and we list them under Fishers, Indiana. Cremation providers often collect from surrounding towns, hospitals and hospices as well, but coverage and any mileage charge vary — ask Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel whether they serve your address and what transportation is included in the price.
How do I get an itemized quote from Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel?
Call Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel at +1 317-841-7878 and ask for their General Price List. Under the FTC Funeral Rule, any funeral provider must give you an itemized price list on request and must quote prices over the phone. Line the same items up across providers — the cremation fee, transportation, the basic container, filing the death certificate and certified copies — so you are comparing like with like.
Is this listing verified by Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel?
No. This listing was compiled from public sources and has not been claimed by Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel, so we cannot confirm the details with the business. Treat the prices and contact details on this page as a starting point and confirm them directly.
Can I get quotes from other Fishers providers too?
Yes. We list 2 cremation providers in Fishers, and the free quote form on this page goes to local providers, not only Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel. Comparing at least three itemized quotes for the same service is the simplest way to tell whether a price is fair.
Prices, ratings and contact details on this page come from the listing we hold for Shirley Brothers Mortuaries & Crematory-Fishers-Castleton Chapel and are refreshed periodically — confirm anything you are relying on directly with the provider.